The Hidden Path to Real Estate Wealth: From Passive Investor to Deal Maker
Episode Summary
In this episode of The Real Estate Investing Club podcast, host Gabriel Petersen sits down with Denis Shapiro from SIH Capital Group to explore the often-overlooked world of affordable housing and hospitality investments. Denis shares his unique journey from being a limited partner (LP) investor to becoming a general partner (GP) operating over 300 apartments and 60 hotel rooms.
Key Takeaways:
- How Denis transformed from a government employee investing passively to a full-time real estate operator
- Why affordable housing provides better cash flow opportunities than luxury properties
- The critical importance of winter month closings in seasonal markets
- Lessons learned from investing in three Ponzi schemes and how to avoid them
- The blueprint for executing a complete business plan in under 11 months
- Why workforce housing in secondary markets outperforms Class A properties in prime locations
How Do You Transition from Passive Real Estate Investing to Becoming an Active Operator?
The path from limited partner to general partner isn’t typical, but it offers unique advantages. As Denis Shapiro explains, “I started from the investment side. I truly, when I connect with our investors, I truly understand where they’re coming from because I was them.”
Starting as an LP investor provides invaluable perspective. Denis began his journey in 2012, fresh out of college while working for the government. He discovered private investments when seeking tax-efficient strategies: “I started seeing the benefits of the private investments because I got great appreciation on the stock side, but I never got good cash flow… the first fund I ever invested in was like a nice debt fund that paid double digits.”
The transition happened gradually over 13 years. First, Denis invested in one deal, then multiple deals, eventually forming an investment club where he participated in 12-15 LP investments. This experience analyzing dozens of deals from the investor’s perspective gave him deep insights into what makes a successful operation. By 2022, he left his government job to operate full-time, now managing 300 apartments and 60 hotel rooms through SIH Capital Group.
What Makes an Investment Club Successful for Real Estate Syndications?
Creating an investment club accelerates learning and improves deal selection. Denis formed his club with just two other high-level executives, using technology to enhance their analysis process. “We had a Slack channel where we really got to dive in and really analyze these,” Denis shares. “We always had to get that buy in. We always had to really talk through the deals.”
The key to their success was diversity of perspective. One member was highly analytical, another was tech-focused, and Denis sourced deals. This dynamic forced thorough vetting: “It was funny because one of the people was a really hard no and one of the people was always a really easy yes. So when I found the deal, I kind of knew if I could mend the gap.”
This rigorous process taught valuable lessons about deal analysis. They evaluated operators based on communication frequency, transparency, and actual performance versus projections. These insights later shaped how Denis structures his own operations and investor relations.
Why Is Affordable Housing a Better Investment Than Luxury Properties?
Affordable housing, particularly workforce housing, offers superior risk-adjusted returns compared to Class A luxury properties. Denis emphasizes this counterintuitive truth: “We’re still in affordable housing. We love workforce housing. Particularly we love C class with B class finishes.”
The numbers tell the story. While luxury properties might command $2,500-3,000 monthly rents, workforce housing at $800-900 provides better cash flow stability. “If you’re talking about luxury, man, when we have the pandemic, when we have the recession, the people who are making 250K are the people that are getting laid off a lot of the time,” Denis explains. “The people who are making, you know, 50 to 60K, they tend to still be working.”
Government support programs like Section 8 add another layer of security. These programs provide guaranteed rent payments and long-term tenant stability. As Denis notes, “Every single B and C class property, literally 50% of the tenant base qualifies for Section 8.” This creates a natural floor for occupancy and rent collection, even during economic downturns.
How Can You Identify and Avoid Real Estate Investment Ponzi Schemes?
Experience teaches hard lessons. Denis candidly shares: “I’ve invested in three Ponzi schemes, which is awesome… As an LP, I have cut my teeth.” These painful experiences provided valuable education about red flags to watch for in syndication deals.
Key warning signs include returns that seem too good to be true, especially when they’re guaranteed or fixed. “If the returns are too good to be true, if they’re guaranteed and they’re fixed… There’s just so many red flags,” Denis warns. Social media presence can also be telling: “If you see them on social media and they never say anything negative, and it’s just all positive, positive, positive.”
The most important factor is knowing your partner. Even as a limited partner, you’re still in a partnership. Thorough due diligence on the operator’s track record, communication style, and transparency is essential. Denis learned this the hard way but emphasizes the value: “The highest ROI you’re going to have is from those complete mistakes… I am pretty sure I will never get hit by another Ponzi scheme again.”
What Secondary Markets Provide the Best Opportunities for Real Estate Investors?
Secondary and tertiary markets often outperform primary markets for cash flow investments. Denis focuses on areas outside Cleveland, particularly North Canton, Stark County, and Portage County. “We really like Kent because we love the Kent State University. We like these markets that are not really talked about and they don’t have the double digit population growth, but it’s nice and steady.”
The strategy targets markets with stable employment bases and educational institutions. University towns provide consistent rental demand from students, faculty, and staff. These markets may lack the appreciation potential of high-growth areas, but they offer superior cash flow and stability.
Market selection criteria should focus on income sustainability rather than population growth. Denis looks for areas where the local workforce can afford $800-900 rents comfortably, creating a large pool of qualified tenants. This approach has enabled them to execute business plans quickly and efficiently.
How Important Is Timing When Closing Real Estate Deals in Seasonal Markets?
Closing timing in four-season markets significantly impacts execution success. Denis shares crucial advice: “Pay attention to when a deal closes. Especially if you’re in, you know, four season environment. If you’re looking at underwriting and you’re looking at projections and that deal is closing in November and December, realistically speaking, the operator shouldn’t be doing too much.”
His Ravenna, Ohio deal exemplifies perfect timing. Closing in November 2024, they strategically delayed major renovations: “Shouldn’t be evicting a lot of people in December, January, February. It’s hard to lease up in those months.” Instead, they did minimal evictions during winter, then “ramped up in March. And then basically from March to like May… in like a three month period, went completely, completely done.”
This patient approach enabled them to complete their entire business plan in under 11 months, transforming rent roll from $15,000 to $23,000 monthly. The lesson is clear: operators claiming aggressive year-one projections while closing in winter months likely haven’t accounted for seasonal realities.
What Distinguishes Great Real Estate Operators from Average Ones?
Communication frequency and quality separate exceptional operators from the rest. Through investing in 12-15 different syndications, Denis experienced the full spectrum: “We got the monthly ones, we got the quarterly ones, we got the detailed ones, we got the no communication at all.”
The best operators maintain consistent, transparent communication regardless of performance. They share both successes and challenges, providing investors with genuine insight into operations. This transparency builds trust and demonstrates competence in handling adversity.
Denis applies these lessons to his own operations. At SIH Capital Group, investors speak directly with partners involved in deals, not investor relations intermediaries. “We don’t have an investor relations person. All the partners are in there. So you’re gonna talk to one of the partners that are involved on the deal.”
How Can Small Investors Build Wealth Through Real Estate Syndications?
Starting small with limited partner investments provides education while building wealth. Denis began with a single investment while working his government job, seeking tax-efficient strategies beyond traditional stocks. “I got great appreciation on the stock side, but I never got good cash flow,” he recalls, highlighting syndications’ unique advantage.
The key is treating early investments as education. Join or form an investment club to leverage collective wisdom and spread risk across multiple deals. Use technology like Slack or Discord to facilitate ongoing deal analysis and discussion with other investors.
Most importantly, don’t expect perfection. “Don’t get into investment and think you’re gonna have a perfect record. It just doesn’t happen. You’re gonna have your misses,” Denis advises. These misses provide valuable education that improves future decision-making. The goal is learning while earning, building expertise that can eventually support a transition to active investing if desired.
Conclusion
Denis Shapiro’s journey from government employee to managing over $50 million in real estate assets demonstrates that success in real estate doesn’t require starting with massive capital or connections. By focusing on overlooked markets, prioritizing cash flow over appreciation, and learning from both successes and failures, investors can build substantial wealth through affordable housing investments.
The key takeaways from Denis’s experience are clear: start as a limited partner to learn the business, focus on workforce housing in stable secondary markets, pay attention to operational timing, and always prioritize thorough due diligence on operators. Most importantly, view mistakes as education rather than failure – they provide the highest ROI in terms of future decision-making.
Want to learn more about our guest? Connect here: sihcapitalgroup.com
Want to learn more about the REI Club Podcast? Click here: https://www.therealestateinvestingclub.com
Want to grow your business with ads? Join our sister company here: https://www.kaizenmarketingagency.com
Want to invest in Gabe’s next deal? Click here: https://www.kaizenpropertiesusa.com
Want to join our community of active investors? Click here: https://linktr.ee/gabepetersen